[2] Judge Brian S. Miller dismissed the case and subsequently ordered Hobbs to pay legal fees incurred by the singer in the amount of $17,590. No. The suspicious part about this is that in a deposition taken in 2009, Terry Hobbs had the very same allegations implied against him that Billy Stewart made in 2013, four years later, but this time the implications were made by Natalie Maines lawyers. Echols lawyer, Patrick Benca, reviewed evidence earlier this year that was thought to have been lost. Jackie Jr. Hicks came to the Hobbs' residence after he was informed of the encounter. I TOOK AARON TO TODD AND DANAS HOUSE AND UM, TODD ASKED AARON IF HE MIGHT KNOW DID CHRIS OR MICHAEL SAY ANYTHING TO HIM, TO THE EFFECT WHERE THEY MIGHT BE. The reason for this is that is that there is an abundance of evidence that shows the three are innocent and at the same time, there is some circumstantial evidence that shows they may be guilty. RIDGE OKAY, THATS WHAT IM GETTING TO, BUT YOU HAVE BEEN THERE ON OCCASION WITH BUDDY? In his first interview, taken shortly after the murders, he claims he went home in the early afternoon but then changes his story and puts himself in Lakeshore at 4:30. This lends credibilty to the theory that Stevie did in fact go home, and even ate some dinner. When questioned later by police, he claims that on the day of the murders he was heading out to meet up with Jesse Misskelley at his Lakeshore trailer but never met up with him. Buddy allegedly confessed that when the four returned to the truck, Terry and David looked to the teens and promised to kill them if they ever spoke of the crime to anyone. Who killed three eight year old boys in West Memphis? : r - reddit And uh Steve was suppose to come by (not audible) before dark I thank it was bout yeah it was bout this time a year it git dark around 8 oclock or so, and he said he told em to be back before dark. Lastly, even David Jacoby, friend to Terry Hobbs, testified that when Terry arrived at his home at 5:30, he asked Terry where Stevie was. 6 Q. The hearing was to allow the victim's . Jacoby likely felt at that time that the only thing to do to protect himself was to put himself as far away from Hobbs as possible. RIDGE: DID YOU EVER TELL ANYDODY ABOUT IT? He was most likely placed near the tree becase one of the perpetrators used the tree as support in order to enter the water. was terry hobbs ever found - wowdigitalmedia.com thanks for the recommendation!! And, since Pam regularly made dinner at 4:30, Stevie knew that dinner was going to be around this time. AND THAT WHITE TANK TOP MAN. One of the 8-year-olds is Hobbs' stepson, Stevie Branch. For whatever reason, if this all is the truth, something went wrong, and that was the day that the boys tragically got caught spying. Michael was almost immediately rendered unconscious ( I believe because he was attacked first). And, according to Buddys cousins, Rex Heath and Charlotte Bly, not only does Buddy not have an alibi for the night of the 5th, its a possibility he lied to police about what he did that night. A Calhoun County man has been missing for weeks now, leaving his family searching for answers. In March 2022,Damien Echols said in a tweet that hell be back in court on June 23 with his law team as they try to get access to DNA, found in the case evidence, to a lab for testing. He also confirmed that one of the teens, Buddy Lucas, had admitted to his involvement in the murders with the other three men. In truth, this theory would finally explain and clarify, really,why the boys had animal hair on them if they were pulled from the water. The question whether the mark on Stevies left eyebrow is a bite mark or not has been the subject of great debate by experts and followers of the case for years. Currently, Hobbs has not been charged with anything related to the murders. And finally, if Terry claims he never saw Stevie that day (despite statements from Jacoby, Jamie Ballard and her sister and mother) there is one extremely significant question Terry has to answer: why did Stevie have partially digested vegetables in his stomach? Additionally, the act of biting the scrotum and stabbing the groin area speaks volumes about the identity of the killer. It is likely that you will come away from this with a clear understanding of who murdered Stevie Branch, Michael Moore and Chris Byers and why. He most likely began to tie up one side of Stevie using a figure eight knot and then went to Michael and tied up one side of him with a square knot. BLY BUDDY UM, LEFT A FEW MINUTES BEFORE THE KIDS GOT KILLED AND SHE SAID, HE DIDNT COME BACK UNTIL THE NEXT DAY. In 2011, after 18 years in prison, the three innocent men were released on an Alford Plea. NARLENE: She meant the mommy, the daddy and the son,(LG) she said I dont know whats going on over there and she said, they are making me nervous, shes a christian girl, she said and I got out of there, I said yeah, I get bad feelings around them too. two hours to clean up the blood at the scene. From there, the police focused on finding clothes, speaking with the families, taping off the area, etc and possibly some small searching of the area. RIDGE: WHEN I SAY HAVING SEX IS THAT WHAT YOUR DESCRIBING? These boards were right next to the clubhouse which means that when the boys were caught, they most likely would have been caught very close to where these boards lay, easily seen to the naked eye. According to Pams family, Stevie was terrified of Terry. Michael, being the first one attacked, was hit so violently and with such anger, that he was almost immediately rendered unconscious. Terry claims that he dropped Amanda off with Bobby, Davids wife and that he and David then scoured the neighborhood looking for Stevie, which makes no sense. WHAT DID YOU ALL HIDE AND WAIT FOR THEM?AARON: YEAH (YES) WILL WE ALWAYS. In addition to Billys statements and the similar questions asked in the 2009 deposition that both pointed to Terry Hobbs being an alleged homosexual or bisexual man, the criminal profiler Brent Turvey claimed in 1996 that whoever committed this murder was a closet homosexual who projected a macho image. transfer betterment to vanguard. This too, may have further contributed to the injuries on the left side of his face. Yup. SO THIS FRIGHTENED ME, SO I GOT AARON OUT OF THERE AND WE WENT HOME. CHRISTY, I WAS TALKING TO A GIRL NAMED CHRISTY AND SHE TOLD ME THAT SHE THOUGHT THEY HAD FOUND ONE OF THE BODIES. Terrys own daughter allegedly told family members, including her mother, grandmother, cousin and aunt that she had been abused by her dad and two family members even claimed to have walked in on Terry abusing his daughter. I think Michelle died of a broken heart, possibly organ failure due to drug abuse. Terry Hobbs was reported missing from Kinard on April 20, but his family said the last time anyone. According to Terrys ex wife, Terry Hobbs first wife had claimed in their divorce papers that he molested their son. So that would prove that there are only two reason why Jacoby would lie to protect Hobbs: its either because he participated in the murders himself or he knows Hobbs did it and he has known it for many years. Mark Byers stated that Terry arrived at his home sometime after Meeks left. Additionally, a bite on the face during murders/attacks is not only common in homosexual attacks, like a bite to the scrotum is, but it also common in Battered Child Syndrome. This means that the boys had most likely arrived to the Blue Beacon Woods before the four men did, crossing over from the west side of the drainage ditch to the east side of the drainage ditch, on a log that lay across the ditch at the south end. BLY HE WAS SUPPOSE TO GO MEET JESSIE MISSKELLEY OUT AT LAKESHORE. Before I go over the timeline of how the day of May 5th 1993 might have unfolded, there is available evidence that is extremely pertinent to understanding what happened that day. It is completely illogical to believe that LG would have driven nearly ten minutes away to get the phone number of someone who was in walking distance from him. Its been so long ago you know it may not be in the right order but I know he did come over around 5:30/6 oclock and we played the guitar for a while and then he said he had to go. When the boys were found, along with their clothes the following day, there were two pairs of underwear and 5 socks missing from the crime scene. What this means is that the men would have only needed to briefly remove their shoes before entering the water. Then for a time, I thought it was JMB. Local 24 News EXCLUSIVE: Terry Hobbs on his new memoir on the West 9pm at night, and according to her, he was wearing a white shirt and tie. This case has just been trapped in my mind since I heard about it and it breaks my heart every single day. In addition to that, when the boys autopsies were performed, animal hair was discovered on them. Steven Branch had lacerations on his penis which were probably self-inflicted indicating a sexualized child, usually associated with sexual abuse. According to Bennies statement, Terry stopped for a moment to yell, Im going to teach your fucking ass! Its not so much what the boys saw by itself, but what they saw coupled with Michael kicking Terry. When reading her first statements to police, it raises serious doubts about her alleged sighting of the three boys. Pam Hobbs divorced Terry Hobbs in 2004 and has reversed her position on the West Memphis Three's guilt. (Interestingly, Chris was referred to as the 3rd child in the alleged confessions. Pam walked past him to the car and had to find out from her 4 year old daughter, Amanda, that they couldnt find Stevie. Is there any other reason why hed admit on national television that he lied? I believe that certainly Buddy, and perhaps LG as well, participated in the crime because of The Bystander Effect; they partook in the crime out of fear and/or compliance, but they did not have intentions to murder. Basically, he believes that Stevie was a sexualized child. In fact, the very first place that he and Pam looked before Pam went to work was Michaels house. Terry Hobbs, however, was not without his defenders. NARLENE: She meant the mommy, the daddy and the son,(LG) she said I dont know whats going on over there and she said, they are making me nervous, shes a christian girl, she said and I got out of there, I said yeah, I get bad feelings around them too. Jared: When they [the police] met you at the restaurant, was it just closer to meet you there as opposed to going to the neighborhood?, Hobbs: Thats where we called them from, so we knew they would be coming up somewhere near there.. AARON: IT WAS EVERY DAY BUT, IT WAS EVERY TIME, BUT IT EVERY TIME BUT UM, THE FRIDAY. It's Terry Hobbs : r/WestMemphisThree - reddit When Hobbs finally contacted the police, he did so from a payphone, even though the boy hadnt returned home at 4 p.m. as instructed, and neither had Christopher or Michael. And also bit him in his penis perhaps once or twice. To corroborate this letter, Byers and Hicks lawyer and investigator contacted Bennies friend, Billy Stewart. Narlene interjected herself all over this case. They both have bias, so I think its important to keep that in mind. West Memphis Three: Who is the real killer behind the brutal - MEAWW A year or so after Buddy admitted to Bennie of his involvement, he also allegedly confessed to Billy Stewart and described to him what happened. Which means that when Natalies lawyers dug into Terry Hobbs past, there were obviously some people who made similar allegations to the ones Billy made 4 years later. That makes sense to me. ! Retired FBI profiler, John Douglas, as well as profiler Brent Turvey both believed the entire attack was punitive in nature and that the perpetrator was teaching the boys a lesson for either a real or percieved transgression. The nudity and tying is what makes it even more sick than just bashing their heads in. Why didnt Terry search for Stevie at the Moores? A few pages prior, he writes "Damien and Jason had no indicative violence in their pasts, and while Jessie was known for a hot temper, he channeled his aggression into pursuits such as wrestling." David Jacoby is the key to this case. He was home during the evenings when his wife worked a four-hour shift at Catfish Island. No. YOU JUST THOUGHT IT WAS BAD? (1, 2,) He originally claims to have asked his aunt for a ride home, that she said no, and he left and began to walk home. SIDEWAYS AND WE GOT IN OUR CLUB HOUSERIDGE: OKAYRIDGE: OKAY. YEA IT WAS BUT, I WOULD THINK SO, IN ORDER TO HOLD ALL 3 LITTLE 8 YEAR OLDS THAT IT WAS PRETTY STURDY, AARON: IN ROBIN HOOD UH, THE PLACE WHERE THE BOARDS ARE. French reported that prior to the incident she had gone to the Hobbs' home after hearing what she believed to be a domestic dispute. Both Guy and Stewart have tried since 1994, thirteen years before Terry and David were even suspects, to tell the authorities what they had been told. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Memphis_Three. THAT HAD ON THE WHITE TANK TOP. The reason why Chriss skin was removed but his penis remained, i.e. RIDGE: OKAY. Again, Ill let you decide. Richard took another polygraph saying that LG was not with him the night of the 5th and he passed. The way the three boys were tied, wrist to ankle, as opposed to wrist to wrist, ankle to ankle, is one of the most unique aspects to this case. After Stevie was gone, he expected her to get over it right away and said she was neglecting her wifely duties. He later changed that story and claimed she told them they were at some apartments. Why in the world were the two men (or Terry alone) searching for the boys when it was light out if Terry had already said that Stevie could stay out till 8:00 pm? I think its open to interpretation. My belief is that these items were used in the clean up. In the autopsy reports, it was concluded that Michael was swiftly and violently attacked and was likely unconscious for almost the entire assault on the boys. Not only did Terry whip Stevie for not listening, but Pam was strict as well. One mystery that has plagued people who have followed the case, is why it appeared that Stevie and Chris were tortured while Michael was not. WE NEED TO GO TO THE CLUB HOUSE. Ive been trying to bridge what Peretti said happened with what the defense experts said. I believe he intended to terrify and threaten them so they would never, ever speak of what they had seen. For one, LGs other aunt saw him at her work at approx. During a special presentation at CrimeCon 2022 Las Vegas, former New York State prosecutor Jim Clemente joined Truth & Justice podcast host, Bob Ruff, and investigative journalist, George Jared, to take a deep dive into a conversation Jared previously had with Terry Hobbs. Whats more suspicious, is that Buddy originally told police that he was with his family barbecuing on the 5th but when his mother spoke to Fogelman, she never mentions anything about Buddy being home with her that night. They were so sure that the murders were part of a satanic ritual done by teenagers, and were so desperate to make sure that Aarons answers revealed that, that eventually Aarons statements began to get more and more fantastical and implausible. (3) She claimed to have seen them near the spot they were murdered somewhere between 6:00 and 6:30. If Terry wanted things to turn sexual, his predatory mind would have thought of ways to lead things in that direction.